HOME      Kinkead Ridge   Awards & Reviews 
 

November 2012

Kinkead Ridge 2010 Cabernet Franc and 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon both medalled at the 2012 American Wine Competition despite a cross-country delivery to Portland, Oregon.

October 2012

2010 Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon
from a fan...

"the 2010 CS is quite possibly the best wine I have ever had. Yours is the only wine we get that I make a concerted effort (and it's hard) to put down in our cellar to age. We still have a little 2008 PV. I put down the odd other bottle but they are seldom better later. But yours ages wonderfully."

2010 Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Franc
From cellartracker.com:

Deep ruby red; cedar and floral nose; red and black fruits, herbs, big tannins and good acidity making for a medium finish. While the nose isn't jumping out of the glass like the 2008 did, this has a great, well balanced palate. I'm a big Bordeaux fan and I'm not exaggerating when I say that if tasted blind, I would have guessed right bank Bordeaux...seriously. Rated 92March 2011

2008 Cabernet Sauvignon: Gold Medal, Finger Lakes International Wine Competition. Only two Ohio wineries won gold medals for a vinifera wine.

October 2010

2008 Cabernet Sauvignon: Silver Plus Medal (judged young), American Wine Society
2008 Cabernet Sauvignon: Wine of Merit, Jefferson Cup Invitational (i.e. in Top 70 of 600+ wines)
2008 Cabernet Franc: Silver Medal (judged young)
2008 Syrah: Wine of Merit, Jefferson Cup Invitational (i.e. in Top 70 of 600+ wines)

March 2011

Another fantastic review of the 2008 Cabernet Franc:
"hey nancy, just wanted to say hello and pass on a note that I got from a friend of mine. he's out in northern california and he has a little circle of wine geek friends that do these dinner parties. i guess that they all individually take notes and score wines then compare them collectively. So it was your cab franc, a nickel and nickel cab and then a hutchinson cab that garnered a 95+ robert parker score. needless to say your cab franc won the tasting and was 3 points average higher than both of the other two wines."
 

2010

2008 Cabernet Franc: Jefferson Cup. Only 20 wines of over 600 judged received this honor.

2008 Cabernet Sauvignon, Winner, Ohio/Michigan wine Clash.
http://www.ohiovsmichiganwineclash.com/

February 2010

Loren Sonkin rates 2007 Cabernet Sauvignon and 2007 Cabernet Franc 90 points:

Review from Loren Sonkin on Mark Squires Bulletin Board. 90 points. "I think this is one of the best wineries in Ohio and certainly the best for red wines. 2007 was also one of the best vintages in these parts. I served this blind and Jeff thought it was local. Most others found it to be very good although no one pegged it for a Cab. Light ruby in color, clear and bright. The nose has pretty strawberry notes with some cherries. A bit of an herbal note as well. Nice texture. This is a very good red wine. I don't know about "varietal correctness" but it is delicious. For $17 Ohio, I am going to lay down a few. I think it ages well for 5 to 10 years as it got better all night long. (90 pts.)"

Loren Sonkin rates this wine 90 points on cellartracker.com.

"IMO, this is the best winery for red wines in Ohio. And, 2007 was the best vintage in these parts in a long time. Perhaps it truly will be a vintage of the century. I drank this bottle over two nights. $18 Ohio. Ruby in color with some opaque qualities to it. On the first night, it showed plenty of raspberries and some cassis. While these remained, on Day 2, a bit of green tobacco and an underlying earthiness came out. On the palate, this was medium bodied raspberry juice on Day 1, but it put on weight and showed much more complexity on Day 2. Layers of fruit and earth. I think a year or two in the cellar (or at least a couple of hours in a decanter), but this is a quality Cab Franc. It does not have any off green flavors. Want to impress someone with the quality of an Ohio red wine? This is it. And, the price is very reasonable for the quality."

Recent posting from blog Two Dogs, a Flamingo and a Bottle of Wine about our Petit Verdot. See http://dogswine.blogspot.com/2009/07/kinkead-ridge-petit-verdot-2005.html

"I've been sitting on half a dozen bottles of the Kinkead Ridge 2005 Petit Verdot for almost two years since its release, tasting it only at the winery on two occasions. Yesterday evening I was moving some wine from one location to another and decided it was time to see if the wait paid off. Dinner was two small lamb chops and some rosemary roasted potatoes and the weather was cool for this time of year. Out came the cork from the bottle.

The wine was intensely dark purple, almost black in the glass. After five or ten minutes it began to open up and offer dark, ripe plums and cassis and a few super dark cherries thrown in the mix. The nose was earthy and there were a few herbs and flowers coming out of the glass as well. The taste was equally about dark fruit, plums and blackberries mostly. The wine was very tannic, but the tannin never interfered with the fruit. During the course of the evening the tannin finally began to settle a little though it still had a wonderful grip. There was good acid and with the tannins softening the finish was smooth, clean and long.

I've had numerous bottles of Kinkead Ridge's wine, both red and white over the last few years and have appreciated all of them. Some are obviously better than others and bottle for bottle my favorite is still their Riesling. This wine, however, is the best I've had from them. It's hard to imagine that it could get any better. Total production was only 76 cases and the wine checked in at an almost perfect 13.4% alcohol. I'm very happy there are five more bottles in the cellar. "

This is an interesting article about wine competitions. We enter very few, and there seems to be justification in this story why. "A survey of approximately 65 judging panels between 2005 and 2008 yielded just 30 panels that achieved anything close to similar results, with the data pointing to "judge inconsistency, lack of concordance--or both" as reasons for the variation. The phenomenon was so pronounced, in fact, that one panel of judges rejected two samples of identical wine, only to award the same wine a double gold in a third tasting." Click here to read the article.

2006 Revelation, Rated the Top Red Wine in the 2008 Ohio/Michigan Wine Clash, Bronze, American Wine Society
Sold out before we could enter it into later competitions. When it won this bronze it was only in bottle a short period of time.
2006 River Village Cellars Syrah, Bronze, American Wine Society. Sold out before we could enter it into later competitions. When it won this bronze it was only in bottle a short period of time.
2006 River Village Cellars Cabernet Franc, Silver, Finger Lakes Wine Competition, Bronze, American Wine Society

2007 Cabernet Sauvignon: Silver Medal American Wine Society
2007 Cabernet Sauvignon: Top red wine in the 2nd annual Ohio/Michigan Wine Clash

2008 White Revelation: Gold Best of Appellation, Napa
2008 Riesling: Double Gold Best of Appellation, Napa

 

Kinkead Ridge 2004 Cabernet Franc rated one of the Top 100 Exciting Wine Finds, international list compiled by Tom Stevenson, British editor of the New Sothebys Wine Encyclopedia and publisher of the paperback Wine Report 2008. "Succulent, intensely flavored fruit, ripe, supple tannins, and a truckload of flavors--from cherries, cassis, chocolate, and cream, to vanilla and coconut."--Sandra Silfven, Atlantic Northeast editor of the 2008 Wine Report "This shows what promise there is in Ohio." --Tom Stevenson


Please note: We did not enter any wine into the Finger Lakes International Competition this year, as I was on vacation when the deadline passed.

Ann Boucher names 2005 Petit Verdot her 2007 Wine of the Year. "My reasons for this choice and the long introduction are simple; the wine is very good and by industry standards is completely unknown. Furthermore, consider that the vineyards are still young and owners, Ron Barrett and Nancy Bentley, have literally and figuratively only scratched the surface of their site. Give the high quality I have observed this far, I do predict big things from Ripley in the future. Chave Hermitage big? Perhaps not, but I think Kinkead Ridge is producing exciting and novel wines, while at the same time quite literally giving birth to a new fine wine region. For this alone they merit high praise and loyal patronage."
 

"Rest assured, the quality at Kinkead Ridge is very high, and I would argue represents the best in Ohio and possibly the eastern US.  I would also add that yes indeed their terroir is worth expressing!  A good sniff and a quick taste will prove that to anyone.  The important thing to me is that these are not wines of ego, rather they are clearly wines of place.  Ron and Nancy have worked hard to clearly express the virtues of their vineyard, and have given the wine drinking public something rare indeed…  an entirely new wine region, with its own unique combination of flavors and aromas.  To me this is exactly what fine wine is all about." Click here to read this stunning review.
--Chuck and Ann Boucher, Serendipity Wine Shop, Columbus

2007 American Wine Society Compeition
GOLD MEDAL: 2006 Viognier/Roussanne
Silver Medal: 2005 Cabernet Franc
This competition was held a full month earlier than last year, the beginning of October. The red wines were only released in September after a May bottling, and were probably too young to be sent to this competition.

2007 Finger Lakes Wine Competition

GOLD MEDAL: 2004 Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon. 2000+ wines; 141 gold medals; 15 for Cabernet; only one from Ohio. Ours.

2006 American Wine Society Competition, November 8-9, Baltimore Maryland

DOUBLE GOLD. 2004 Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Franc. Double Gold means every one of the six judges gave the wine a Gold Rating.

SILVER. 2004 Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon.

BRONZE. 2004 Kinkead Ridge Syrah

BRONZE: 2005 Kinkead Ridge Viognier/Roussanne

 

Kinkead Ridge 2003 Viognier/Roussanne honored as one of the TOP 100 Exciting New Wine Finds in the World by Tom Stevenson in the 2006 Wine Report paperback.  Listed in the TOP FOUR New Up-and-Coming Producers in the Global Report/Atlantic Northeast. 2003 Viognier/Roussanne listed in the TOP 10 of Most Exciting or Unusual Wines, Atlantic Northeast.  The review is in the Archive link, December 2005. Tom Stevenson also edits the New Sotheby's Wine Encyclopedia. This book is available in your local bookstores or on Amazon.

 SILVER MEDAL. Kinkead Ridge 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon. This is our first entry into this prestigious competition. 

 

 

Kinkead Ridge wines garner three medals at 2005 American Wine Society International Commercial Competition in Las Vegas.  2003 Cabernet Sauvignon, Bronze; 2003 Syrah, Bronze, 2004 Viognier/Roussanne, Bronze. 
Only one other Ohio winery won medals for vinifera wines. Congratulations to Ferrante, Geneva. To see all the results, click here.

Kinkead Ridge won a silver medal at the 2004 competition for their 2002 Revelation Cabernet blend, and a bronze medal for the 2003 Viognier/Roussanne.

July 2007, Re 2006 Viognier/Roussanne:
A wine writer tasted this wine with an importer and colleagues at the Winds, where they were presenting their wines from the south of France, including a new Roussanne-Viognier cuvee. The group was "enormously impressed and amazed. The wine displayed the kind of balance they are trying to achieve."

December 2006
Reviews by Ann Boucher, Serendipity Wine Shop, Columbus, Ohio

Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Franc 2004
I gave this wine to my husband blind and asked him what he thought. He raised the glass to his nose, swirled and took a good sniff. Putting on his best airs, he said, without skipping a beat, "very nice... Cabernet Franc... definitely French." Then he took a good sip into his mouth, swirled and chewed the wine for a moment, and completed his diagnosis, "Bordeaux." Always the business man, he then asked, "how much and what's the stock status?" never guessing he could be wrong about the wines provenance. When I told him it was Kinkead Ridge 2004 Cabernet Franc, his eyes lit up. When I told him that it will retail for $16.99 his jaw dropped. As for stock status, only 355 cases were made. Needless to say not much to go around, and if history is any guide, it will all be gone fast.


River Village Cellars White Wine 2005
This was my first introduction to the wines of Kinkead Ridge. I was floored! Having been in the trade for 20 odd years, I have not tasted a dry white wine from Ohio of equal quality. This wine has a very inviting nose of honeysuckle and apricots. On the palate, it offers lush fruit with a hint of spice. It's surprisingly rich, with a subtle honeyed mid-palate. Unlike many Ohio wines, which can show a hollowness or discontinuity, this wine is complete. The 2005 Viognier/Roussanne clearly proves that with proper care in both the vineyard and cellar, full, complete and delicious dry whites can be made in Ohio. Moreover, I would argue that this wine surpasses most new world efforts with white Rhone grapes, including a few very pricey efforts from California. In short, this is a very good wine at an outstanding price. Trust me, it is time that all wine drinkers give Ohio a second look.

Kinkead Ridge Syrah 2004
This wine brings me back to the cellar of Denis Alary, a top notch producer in Cairanne, a Village appellation in the Cote-du-Rhone. A few years back, I was sampling through various wine in barrel and came upon a Syrah of which Denis was particularly proud. Still very young and closed-up, it was obvious that the wine was going to be great. Similarly, the Kinkead Ridge Syrah is presently closed up and a bit awkward, due to its youth. But there is no doubt that this wine is going places, and I, for one, want to be there when it arrives! Everything about it hints of big things to come -- subtle raspberry, a bit of spice, with a hefty curtain of tannins, obscuring everything from full view.

Definitely not ready to drink, today, but if you are looking for a special and unique wine, that will amply reward, given a little cellar-time, you cannot go wrong with this one. As with everything that Kinkead Ridge produces, quantities are very limited, as only 149 cases were produced in 2004. Get it while you can or you may have to wait until next year.

Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon 2003
Although the wine shows many of the hallmarks of classic Cabernet Sauvignon: black cherry, cassis and artful barrel aging, it also exhibits charming singularities not found in Cabernet from the Napa Valley or Bordeaux. Namely, the wine is not muscular, heavy or in anyway over proportioned. Rather, it's bright and focused, a wine with poise -- more like a well-appointed debutant, than a hulking NFL lineman. We all know the latter, over extracted, over oaked... just plain over the top! Fine for sipping now and then but poorly suited for the table. Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon offers delicate perfume. It is a pretty, almost feminine wine, and brings to mind the great reds of Chinon, Bourgueil or even Cru Beaujolais. A Frenchman would argue that the finesse and perfume comes from the limestone based soil, and I would tend to agree. This is a wine of place, very old world in style, perfectly suited to the table, and unique to Ohio.

 


May, 2006
Bell's Wine Shoppe: Probably the oldest single owner wine shop in Washington, D.C.
"Kinkead Ridge Cabernet 03 Ohio. "This is a dry, medium-bodied, cleanly made Cabernet. The bouquet and flowers are varietal with some added briary notes often found in wines from Bordeaux. Pleasant wine at what appears to be a value price (liquor and wine are highly taxed and notoriously expensive in Ohio)". Jim Stuztman, who donated the tasting bottle says: "These guys review tough on mid-west wines. This is as good a review as they've given to a mid-west wine."

April 2006. G.A. Benton reviews Kinkead Ridge in Columbus Alive. " 
|
Down by the River
"Perusing the aisles of a few select wine stores, I realized time was running out for some delicious Ohio wines. 

Delicious Ohio wines? If you're thinking those three words sound strange together (and who could blame you?) then get off your sudsy beer haunches and check out Kinkead Ridge Vineyards. 

Made in very limited quantities (about 50 to 200 cases per wine), the current stock of Kinkead is quickly dwindling, though it's still possible to find bottles of these southern-Ohio-made winners. 

If you're already on to Kinkead, I'm encouraging you to increase your supply right now. If the wines are new to you, here's a little background. Read more...


 

March 1, 2006 Jon Christensen (Columbus Dispatch) reviews our Viognier/Roussanne
2004 Kinkead Ridge (Ohio River Valley) Viognier-Roussanne ($14.95)
"This remarkable achievement deserves to be compared to the priciest dry whites from France's Rhone Valley. Its rich hints of apricot and other stone fruits, minerally crisp finish, food-accompanying versatility and restrained alcohol put this southern Ohio gem ahead of just about anything close to its price. "

Matt Citriglia's review of the 2004 Viognier/Roussanne... "sublimely fragrant and elegant restrained white wine that would stand up to any of the best that the southern Rhone has to offer"... and the 2003 Cabernet Franc: "Here in Ohio it produces a wonderful moderately tannic red wine with herby red fruit and great fragrance... "Most wineries in Ohio run from vinifera grapes... Ron Barrett and Nancy Bentley took on the challenge and have grown a variety of vinifera right here in Ripley on the limestone ridges." Matt is Ohio's only Master Sommelier. 

Andrew Jones, international wine writer
Kinkead Ridge 2003 Cabernet Sauvignon
WOW rating: 88
"This is the first Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon ever released and replaces the Revelation blend of 2002 and 2001. A small quantity of Petit Verdot was used in the blend. Kinkead Ridge continues to demonstrate that the Ohio River Valley can surprise America with the character and quality of its Cabernet Sauvignon. Whilst this example is not from the greatest vintage and the vines are still relatively young, the result is rewarding. This Cabernet Sauvignon has a healthy ruby color and an aroma of blackcurrants and morello cherries. Small French and American oak casks contribute to the vanilla hints and toasty characteristics. Try this wine with herb-roasted chicken, lamb sprinkled with rosemary and soft cheeses."

Andrew Jones, international wine writer
Kinkead Ridge 2004 Viognier/Roussanne
WOW rating: 88
"Another distinctive dry white blend from Kinkead Ridge, the wine kings of Ripley, Ohio. This stylish wine offers a tempting orange blossom bouquet, followed by hints of kiwi fruit, peaches and tropical fruit on the palate. Its hallmark is finesse and it leaves a lingering aftertaste. Pair this elegant wine with delicately flavored dishes, sushi or seafood risotto."

The Wine Buzz, Volume 3, Number 3, p. 24
Kinkead Ridge mentioned by Chef-Owner Alana (Alanas, Columbus) 
"The encyclopedic wine list runs several pages, and is probably best tackled under the tutelage of sommelier Kevin... The dozen or so glass offerings include a Viognier/Roussanne blend from Kinkead Ridge Winery in Ripley, Ohio."
and 
Chef-Owner Julie Frances (Aioli, Cincinnati)
"While wines like Chateau de la Greffiere, Macon La Roche-Vineuse find favor, local Kinkead Ridge wines are popular too. Their rich, aromatic Viognier/Roussanne makes a delicious pairing with the grilled whole Spanish bass with pancetta, winter squash puree, fennel salad and tapenade."

The Wine Buzz, Volume 3, Number 3, p. 27 WineFinds
"Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon, 2003 (Ohio River Valley); $17.95. Medium bodied and slightly tart, with chocolaty cherry and tobacco flavors." "Kinkead Ridge Cabernet Franc, 2003 (Ohio River Valley); $15.95. Rustic, slightly barnyard nose, but big juicy Cab Franc flavors of cherries, berries and herbs."

From Sandra Silfven, wine writer Detroit Daily News:
October 2005. "The Viognier/Roussanne was another home run. The Cab Franc was an utter delight. I called it a "happy" wine. The nose was so bright, the flavors so over-the-top correct. In my mind, I compared the body and mouth feel to a French red burgundy. It was not the high-extract deal, but very powerful for not having that concentration that is so popular in California. Three days later, the nose was just as sassy."

The Wine Buzz, Volume 3, Number 1, p. 16. 
Kinkead Ridge Viognier/Roussanne, 2004 (Ohio River Valley); $14.95
Floral, citrus and tropical notes on the nose, followed by plenty of fruit -- think kiwi and lime -- and a bit of minerality. Good balance, good acid and nice depth. Only 177 cases of this wine were made. Cheers to winery owners Nancy Bentley and Ron Barrett for trying something new in Ohio.


2004 American Wine Society Competition
w-medals.jpg (48050 bytes)Kinkead Ridge, an Estate Winery has won medals for both its entries in the prestigious American Wine Society Commercial Wine Competition held November 10-11 in Pennsylvania. 1038 wines were entered from 196 wineries in the U.S., Canada, Spain, Germany, Italy, France, Romania, Mexico and Korea; this is the first competition that Kinkead Ridge entered since planting their vineyard in 1999. Both wines that we entered won medals.

2002 Revelation, Silver Medal
2003 Viognier/Roussanne, Bronze Medal

 

March 2005
2002 Revelation,  rated 91 by Andrew Jones, international wine writer. 


Andrew Jones, Editor,  (England) says the following about the 2002 Revelation: 
Rating: 91

"Kinkead Ridge excels again. Just when I thought winemaker Ron Barrett should be best known for white wine, he has produced an exciting Bordeaux-style red blend. Comprising 53% Cabernet Franc, 45% Cabernet Sauvignon and just 2% Petit Verdot, its origin would fool many experts in a blind tasting and could easily be confused for a Médoc of the Cru Bourgeois level.

If Kinkead Ridge can do this with young vines, the future looks very promising indeed...

Revelation tempts one with its vanilla and cherry notes on the nose. These are confirmed along with bramble and blackcurrant on a middleweight palate that leads to a long, smooth finish.

Small volume means full order books, so be brave and order in advance. That will give you a chance to enjoy a rising star from Ripley, Ohio."


2003 Viognier/Roussanne. 
International wine writer Andrew Jones gives this wine a 90. Click here.

December 2003
International wine writer Andrew Jones reviews Kinkead reds. For the text of the article click here

October 2003
eRobertParker.com
Review by Executive Oenophile Member Ed Hatfield.
Click here to read the text.

Click here for the Andrew Jones write-up of 2001 Kinkead Ridge reds.